Chief Justice Alfonse Owiny-Dollo has called on Uganda Law Society (ULS) president Isaac Ssemakadde to apologize to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Ms. Jane Frances Abodo, for remarks allegedly made during a recent symposium. Justice Dollo emphasized the need for reconciliation within the legal fraternity, urging Mr. Isaac Ssemakadde to seek forgiveness to restore civility.
Speaking at the Fifth Northern Annual Bar Bench Law Dinner held in Moroto District, the Chief Justice proposed mediation through Karamoja elders as a path toward resolution.
“I am willing to take Ssemakadde to Karamoja elders if he is ready, to make a sincere apology and bring this bad blood to an end,” he said.
The controversy stems from a symposium organized by the People’s Freedom Front (PFF) in Kampala on November 18, where Mr. Ssemakadde allegedly referred to DPP Abodo as “a pumpkin for a DPP” and “a dimwit.” His remarks ignited widespread public debate about freedom of speech and professionalism within Uganda’s legal community.
Legal action followed, with lawyers Joshua Byamazima and Tony Tumukunde filing a complaint at Buganda Road Chief Magistrates Court on December 4, accusing Mr. Ssemakadde of “insulting the modesty of a woman.” The case is being handled by Chief Magistrate Ronald Kayizzi and has drawn significant public attention.
Adding to the controversy, Members of Parliament from Karamoja, Abodo’s home region, condemned Mr. Ssemakadde’s remarks as disrespectful and demanded a public apology.
Justice Dollo’s involvement has also sparked discussions on the subjudice principle, which discourages commentary on matters before the court. Addressing concerns, Judiciary spokesperson James Mawanda Ereemye clarified that the Chief Justice did not comment on the merits of the case but instead encouraged reconciliation as an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) measure, in line with Uganda’s Constitution.
“The Chief Justice is a strong advocate of ADR, which is legally permissible. His remarks were made in a brotherly manner and do not interfere with ongoing proceedings,” Mr. Ereemye stated.
Mr. Isaac Ssemakadde, known for his bold demeanor, has yet to respond to the Chief Justice’s call. Legal experts and the public are closely watching his next steps, which could have broader implications for resolving conflicts within Uganda’s justice system.
The law dinner, which concluded a three-day forum, featured discussions on legal issues, social events, and a football match. Attendees included DPP Jane Frances Abodo, ULS Vice President Anthony Asiimwe, regional leaders, and representatives from the judiciary and security forces.
